|#||Name||Pos.||College||Previous Pro Club|
|2||Justin Davis||D||New Mexico||Minnesota United (MLS)|
|3||Ropapa Mensah||F||Penn FC (USL)|
|4||Derrick Jones¹||M||Philadelphia Union (MLS)|
|5||Liam Doyle²||D||Ohio State||Swope Park Rangers (USL)|
|6||Ken Tribbett||D||Drexel||Penn FC (USL)|
|8||Vinnie Vermeer⁴||M||NAC Breda (Eredivisie)|
|9||Cameron Lancaster⁵||F||Louisville City FC (MLS)|
|10||Lebo Moloto||M||Lindsey Wilson||Swope Park Rangers (USL)|
|11||Kharlton Belmar||F||VCU||Swope Park Rangers (USL)|
|12||Tucker Hume||F||North Carolina||Ottawa Fury FC (USL)|
|14||Daniel Rios⁵||F||North Carolina FC (USL)|
|15||Jimmy Ockford⁶||D||Louisville||San Jose Earthquakes (MLS)|
|17||Michael Reed||M||New Mexico||San Antonio FC (USL)|
|18||Matt Pickens||GK||Missouri State||Tampa Bay Rowdies (USL)|
|19||Alan Winn||F||North Carolina|
|20||Matt LaGrassa||M||Cal Poly||Reno 1868 (USL)|
|21||Darnell King||D||Florida Atlantic||Tampa Bay Rowdies (USL)|
|22||Bradley Bourgeois||D||Tulsa||Tulsa Roughnecks (USL)|
|23||Taylor Washington||D||George Mason||Pittsburgh Riverhounds (USL)|
|24||Connor Sparrow||GK||Creighton||Real Salt Lake (MLS)|
|27||Kosuke Kimura||D||Western Illinois||Tulsa Roughnecks (USL)|
|30||Bolu Akinyode||M||Seton Hall||North Carolina FC (USL)|
|33||Forrest Lasso⁷||D||Wofford||FC Cincinnati (MLS)|
¹ – acquired by Nashville MLS from Philadelphia Union on May 10 for $175,000 in General Allocation Money and immediately loaned to NSC.
² – contract mutually terminated on August 2.
³ – traded to Phoenix Rising FC on June 13.
⁴ – spent part of 2019 season on loan with Las Vegas Lights FC.
⁵ – on loan from Nashville MLS.
⁶ – joined team on short-term loan from San Jose Earthquakes on July 15, and loan was later extended to end of season on July 31.
⁷ – joined team on loan from FC Cincinnati on July 25.
⁸ – released from team on March 24.