| Accam, David | 02.29.20 | Atlanta United FC |
| Akinyode, Bolu | 03.24.18 | Pittsburgh Riverhounds SC |
| Allen, Brandon | 05.23.18 | Mississippi Brilla FC |
| Anibaba, Jalil | 08.17.20 | at FC Dallas |
| Anunga, Tah Brian | 08.30.20 | Inter Miami CF |
| Badji, Domonique | 02.29.20 | Atlanta United FC |
| Bauer, Josh | 04.22.23 | Los Angeles FC |
| Beckeles, Brayan | 08.12.20 | at FC Dallas |
| Belmar, Kharlton | 03.13.19 | Loudoun United FC |
| Bourgeois, Bradley | 03.24.18 | Pittsburgh Riverhounds SC |
| Bunbury, Teal | 02.27.22 | at Seattle Sounders FC |
| Bwana, Handwalla | 11.04.20 | FC Dallas |
| Cádiz, Jhonder | 10.14.20 | at Houston Dynamo |
| Castellanos, Robert | 08.01.21 | at Toronto FC |
| Cochran, C.J. | 05.16.18 | Inter Nashville FC |
| Cox, Michael | 03.17.18 | at Louisville City FC |
| Danladi, Abu | 02.29.20 | Atlanta United FC |
| Davis, Justin | 03.17.18 | at Louisville City FC |
| Davis, Sean | 02.27.22 | at Seattle Sounders FC |
| Dezart, Joey | 04.26.23 | San Antonio FC |
| Donasiyano, Irakoze | 06.18.21 | at New York Red Bulls |
| Doyle, Liam | 03.17.18 | at Louisville City FC |
| Dunstan, Jordan | 07.25.18 | Atlanta United 2 |
| Edgar, David | 04.07.18 | Charlotte Independence |
| Godoy, Aníbal | 02.29.20 | Atlanta United FC |
| Greguš, Ján | 03.18.23 | at New England Revolution |
| Haakenson, Luke | 04.24.21 | CF Montréal |
| Howell, Ramone | 05.16.18 | Inter Nashville FC |
| Hughes, Josh | 05.16.18 | Inter Nashville FC |
| Hume, Tucker | 03.17.18 | at Louisville City FC |
| James, Ryan | 03.17.18 | at Louisville City FC |
| Johnston, Alistair | 08.12.20 | at FC Dallas |
| Jome, Ismaila | 05.23.18 | Mississippi Brilla FC |
| Jones, Derrick | 05.14.19 | South Georgia Tormenta 2 |
| Kimura, Kosuke | 03.17.18 | at Louisville City FC |
| King, Darnell | 04.13.19 | Memphis 901 FC |
| LaGrassa, Matt | 03.17.18 | at Louisville City FC |
| Lancaster, Cameron | 03.13.19 | Loudoun United FC |
| Lasso, Forrest | 07.27.19 | Indy Eleven |
| Leal, Randall | 02.29.20 | Atlanta United FC |
| Loba, Aké | 07.21.21 | at Columbus Crew |
| Lovitz, Daniel | 02.29.20 | Atlanta United FC |
| MacNaughton, Lukas | 05.06.23 | Chicago Fire FC |
| Maher, Jack | 10.11.20 | at Sporting Kansas City |
| McCarty, Dax | 02.29.20 | Atlanta United FC |
| Medranda, Jimmy | 03.08.20 | at Portland Timbers FC |
| Mensah, Ropapa | 03.17.18 | at Louisville City FC |
| Miller, Eric | 02.29.20 | Atlanta United FC |
| Moloto, Lebo | 03.17.18 | at Louisville City FC |
| Moore, Shaq | 07.30.22 | Vancouver Whitecaps FC |
| Mukhtar, Hany | 02.29.20 | Atlanta United FC |
| Muyl, Alex | 08.26.20 | at Orlando City SC |
| Nealis, Dylan | 04.24.21 | CF Montréal |
| Ockford, Jimmy | 07.17.19 | at Memphis 901 FC |
| Pickens, Matt | 03.17.18 | at Louisville City FC |
| Picault, Fafà | 02.25.23 | New York City FC |
| Panicco, Elliot | 05.25.22 | at Louisville City FC |
| Piñeiro, Rodrigo | 05.02.21 | Inter Miami CF |
| Reed, Michael | 03.17.18 | at Louisville City FC |
| Ríos, Daniel | 03.13.19 | Loudoun United FC |
| Romney, Dave | 02.29.20 | Atlanta United FC |
| Sapong, C.J. | 04.17.21 | FC Cincinnati |
| Shaffelburg, Jacob | 08.21.22 | FC Dallas |
| Shroot, Robin | 03.17.18 | at Louisville City FC |
| Sparrow, Connor | 03.24.19 | at New York Red Bulls II |
| Surridge, Sam | 08.08.23 | Club América |
| Tribbett, Ken | 03.13.19 | Loudoun United FC |
| Tyrpak, Kris | 08.25.18 | Bethlehem Steel FC |
| Vermeer, Vinnie | 03.24.19 | at New York Red Bulls II |
| Washington, Taylor | 03.17.18 | at Louisville City FC |
| Willis, Joe | 02.29.20 | Atlanta United FC |
| Winn, Alan | 03.31.18 | at Bethlehem Steel FC |
| Woodberry, London | 03.17.18 | at Louisville City FC |
| Wyke, Laurence | 04.26.23 | San Antonio FC |
| Zimmerman, Walker | 02.29.20 | Atlanta United FC |
| Zubak, Ethan | 04.09.22 | at Sporting Kansas City |